The Supreme Pizza-Burger Experiment

A few weeks back, I got a message from my good friend David. There was no text. All it had was a photo of a box.

The Box

Here was my response:

I’m going to shit my pants. Where are you?

He replied, “Cermak Produce on North Ave. At least it’s reduced fat!

I texted him back. I said, “It’s like staring at the face of God and realizing that He hates you.

Then I drove right over and bought the very same box in the photo. I clearly have no impulse control. It’s why my life is both a resounding failure and an amazing success at the same time. I actually cancel out my own existence.

As you can see, these are Supreme’s Pizza-Burgers. According to the box, they are a “Beef Pattie Blended With Pizza Sauce.” They also have a cheese center. Apparently they’re also reduced fat. Thank God.

So last Saturday night, I decided to make these burgers in the best way I knew how. Alone, and drunk. Technically, I wasn’t alone, I guess. My cat Cricket was there (she’s always home), and my roommate Craig (of ABV Chicago podcast fame). And I guess I wasn’t drunk. So, I wasn’t alone and drunk. I lied.

I had a terrific master plan: I would sous-vide them with my new Anova Precision Cooker, which I got for the miraculous low price of $99 because I managed to get in on their Kickstarter campaign really early (this thing is sick, by the way). Then I would sear them. Then I would dip them into a “spaghetti sauce,” like the box recommended. Then, I’d add mozzarella, broil them, and shove them into my burger orifice.

For those of you who don’t know what a sous-vide machine is, this bad boy has a few different names like immersion circulator or water oven. This machine is placed in a vat of water (in my case, a stock pot), and it heats the water to a precise temperature – down to 1/10th of a degree. You put your food in a vacuum sealed bag and let the food cook gently until it comes to temp. The results are nothing short of spectacular. Eggs poach into silk, steaks come out a perfect medium rare, and angels sing whenever you use it. The angels mostly sing if you’re tripping on acid.

My InspirationFirst, I would need courage. This is what courage looks like.Supreme's Pizza-BurgerHere is a glorious photo of the box. As you can see, it’s extremely sexual.

Frozen PattyHere is one of the frozen patties. They weigh in at 2-2/3 ounce, which is actually pretty small. Most of them had a severe case of freezer burn, which is ideally the best scenario for gross meat, because who cares.Ragu Grilled Meat SauceFor the spaghetti sauce, I looked through the grocery store for the most potentially disappointing tomato-based abomination I could find. Here we have Ragú brand Meat Creations Grilled Steak Flavor. Here is my review for this sauce: Don’t.Heat the SauceI heated up the spaghetti sauce for the burger. Even though the instructions don’t say to heat up the sauce, I did it anyway, because I am a culinary genius.Sous Vide DisasterI placed my patties into my “vacuum bags,” aka shitty Ziploc bag knockoffs, and secured them with high-tensile technology (chip clips) to the side of the stock pot so they wouldn’t get stuck in my precious sous-vide machine. The directions said to heat them up until they reached 160° F, which is the temperature for well-done burgers. This was the 9843957983th bad sign. But to be fair, 160° is just over the mark where e. coli bacteria get annihilated, so that’s what the FDA says to cook your ground beef too so you don’t get severe diarrhea. At least the Supreme company likes to play it safe. Not like ol’ Dannis Ree.

Also, yes, I know my counter is a mess. I’m a 33 year old bachelor. Leave me alone.Sous Vide BurgersHere are the burgers. I kept them in there for like an hour. I’m real precise. They were already leaking some kind of cheese from their open pores. Reminds me of when I was a teenager.SearNobody likes pale burgers, or self-loathing Asian men, so I figured I’d give these puppies a quick sear for some color. They were already rubbery as hell anyway so who gives a shit. I seared them on my oil-burned stainless steel pan.Sauce BathNext, the burgers took a dip in the Ragú brand Meat Creations Grilled Steak Flavor tomato sauce (again, don’t). After a taste of the sauce I genuinely felt sorry for them.Cheese the BurgersTo make things healthier, I added a slice of cheap-ass mozzarella cheese, because what can I say, I roll heavy. And what the fuck kind of pizza burgers are stuffed with American cheese? That’s messed up.BroiledAfter a quick trip into the broiler, these puppies actually looked…kind of good. You might not be able to polish a turd, but you sure can shellac it in a coating of toasted cheese.

Finished Pizza BurgerActually kinda pretty, right? I toasted the Martin’s Potato Rolls to give myself at least a little culinary dignity. Martin’s Potato Rolls are the best. If you find them at your local grocery store, buy them. They’re slightly sweet, squishy, and perfect for smallish burgers. Normally I like to dress my burgers up a bit, but you know, there’s plenty of beauty in simplicity, just like me.Burger InsideHere is the cross-section, so you clowns can see the cheese oozing out from the middle. I’m sure you were dying to see the surprise inside.

And of course – how did it taste?

The answer: Fucking gross. Sorry, Supreme’s Pizza-Burgers. I’m genuinely not trying to be a dick. They had this strange flavor, kind of a cross between burnt rubber mixed with oregano and tomato paste, with the texture of meatloaf compressed under a cinderblock. I was actually kind of stunned at how weird they were. Plus that meat-flavored spaghetti sauce? My God. The sauce has a really strange smoky taste to it, mixed with some kind of beef and yeast extract (yeast extract is an additive in foods to make them taste more savory) that ended up driving this whole atrocity right off a cliff. And the American cheese in the middle — it looked like good ol’ melty burger cheese, but it was strangely thin and flavorless. Two words that should not be used to describe most cheese products.

My life is a bottomless abyss.


  16 comments for “The Supreme Pizza-Burger Experiment

  1. Tipsykit
    November 13, 2014 at 11:50 AM

    I think this might be my favorite thing you have ever written. Bravo, Dennis!! Also, this was a terrible thing to read first thing when you wake up. Nothing like starting your day with a mixture of laughter and nausea!

  2. gmac
    November 13, 2014 at 12:46 PM

    Thank you publishing this experiment. If it has saved one person from eating a Supreme’s Pizza Burger, you’ve done mankind a favor.

    Viva d.Ree!

  3. November 13, 2014 at 3:13 PM

    This is truly a sublimely beautiful piece of writing. I take my cap off to you!

  4. Tyler
    November 13, 2014 at 9:26 PM

    Thank you Dennis, this is my new favorite blog. Miss you man!

  5. November 14, 2014 at 8:34 AM

    Bravo! When I first saw the picture of the box I was right there with you. Thank you for sacrificing your palate so that I may be better informed. This has caused a reduction in my poor life choices by a whole 0.00001%!

  6. Neurozach
    December 31, 2015 at 1:09 PM

    Reading all these posts in reverse order is starting to have a Stockholm Syndrome-like effect. I’m starting to fantasize about horrible food things to do to my body.

    Thanks, Dannis Ree!

  7. Shawn
    July 26, 2017 at 5:40 PM

    I remember eating those boxed pizza burgers as a kid. This article was awesomely written. Thanks for the chuckle!

  8. Tim
    August 8, 2017 at 9:26 PM

    We used to just nuke em and eat with ketchup. Pairs nicely with nugrape orange soda. ha

  9. Jeff
    February 28, 2018 at 7:52 PM

    Used to be good ate 3 of them today and tossed the rest out .CRAP CRAP CRAP

  10. GBen
    March 12, 2018 at 5:11 PM


  11. Miranda
    July 1, 2018 at 3:16 PM

    If you don’t want the rest of those pizza burgers, lmk.

  12. Robert Cozza
    July 6, 2018 at 12:26 PM

    Actually I buy them all the time and fry them in a pan and they are delicious by themselves. Maybe you got a bad batch

    • Lori
      September 28, 2018 at 1:09 PM

      Where did you purchase them? I live in the Twin Cities and cannot find anywhere.

      • Corey
        February 1, 2019 at 8:52 AM

        That company is based out of Milwaukee. We just bought some this week and i think they’re pretty good. We didn’t add sauce, but I did throw on sauteed onions, mushrooms and and extra slice of mozzarella. With all food that comes frozen in a box, I’m not looking for some Michelin Star dinner. It’s good enough for what it is, and I can make em in 5-10 minutes. Reynolds Pasties in Milwaukee are also a great frozen food, but they take like an hour to cook in the oven.

        • Pizza burger John
          June 6, 2020 at 8:50 AM

          Extra sauce and mozzarella or provolone
          Basil, oregano and crushed red pepper is a nice addition.
          For extra punishment to your body toast the buns in the greasy pan.

  13. Pizza burger John
    June 6, 2020 at 8:48 AM

    I moved to Bettendorf Iowa from Milwaukee WI last summer.
    The closest grocery store with pizza burgers is a piggly wiggly 88 miles away.
    Thinking about sending my in-laws a check and asking them to buy a cooler And asking them to fill it with ice and pizza burgers and bring it down to me when they come for my wife’s birthday in August?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *